tv Hardball With Chris Matthews MSNBC February 19, 2013 2:00pm-3:00pm PST
of 2008, individual states have slashed their mental health care budgets by almost $2 billion. with sarah palin's home state of alaska cutting almost 35% of its provision for psychiatric illness. in fact, 90 million americans live now in areas where the federal government acknowledges a serious shortage of mental health professionals. and so we come to emerging stories about adam lanza, the sick young man who murdered those children and teachers at sandy hook elementary school. according to a couple local newspaper reporters, adam lanza may have been obsessed with previous mass shootings both here and abroad. according to the very latest statistics, about 1 in 4 of the american population is afflicted by one or more mental disorder. and while the overwhelming majority will never express their illness through an episode of gun violence, it's also abundantly clear that if we don't invest in our mental
health services, then we're unlikely to pick up on any of those who may be minded to do the unthinkable. what we need to decide as a culture is whether we prefer reality television to real action. of course, providing psychiatric help costs money. but if it meant the difference between your child or mine facing a crazed gunman in a school classroom armed with a semiautomatic assault weapon, i think we'd have to agree that would be a very small price to pay. thanks so much for watching. chris matthews and "hardball" is next. the demolition party. let's play "hardball." ♪ good evening. i'm chris matthews in
washington. let me start with this. is what the president started today an all-out challenge to the republicans to stop these crazy manufactured crises we've been having? every few months now we've got another deadline, another abyss, another coming government shutdown. this brinksmanship has become elemental to american politics. republicans now threat ton bring government down to a crashing halt regularly. democrats have to plead with them, practically beg them not to do it. well, this torpedo politics if you you want to call that that, started with newt gingrich in the '90s he was the first right wing radical saying making government work isn't our job, bringing it down is is. destroy it, get people to lose faith in it. lose faith in the ability of the country to do something right. today president obama warned of the casualties, a weakened national defense, the huge loss of jobs, and with it a crippling of the recovery. by the way, with that ax ready to fall, he offered a way out of the endless government shutdowns and the fearfulness and the low morale that goes with it. will the republicans respond to
anything he says now? will they at least try to avoid another slam bang crash in washington? will they pull back from the brink and start climbing mountains instead of crashing over cliffs? oif got two former party chairs with me, republican michael steele and democrat ed rendell, both msnbc political analysts. let's start with the president this morning in the stark terms he laid out for republicans. it's not just the economy that will suffer from the looming cuts next week. that's march 1st. national security will as well and it's seriously at risk. >> already the threat of these cuts has forced the navy to delay an aircraft carrier that was supposed to deploy to the persian gulf, and as our military leaders have made clear, changes like this, not well thought through, not phased in properly, changes like this affect our ability to respond to threats in unstable parts of the world. >> governor rendell, i just wonder what you think would be the situation, the scenario, if it comes to this.
we pick up our paper some day and the newspaper said, carrier group can't make it to persian gulf for lack of funding. i mean, i just wonder if we're ready to face something -- i don't think we ever faced that in world war ii, in korea, in vietnam. we're unable to fight the wars we're in. >> chris, overall it's an incredibly bad situation for the country, and we can argue over who deserves the blame for this, and there's probably blame to go around, but right now the republican party i think is facing a huge crisis because their refusal to move on the sequestration isn't viewed in a vacuum. it's viewed in republicans saying that they won't approve president obama's immigration plan without even knowing what's in it. >> yeah. >> it's viewed in respect to republicans having for the first time filibustered one -- a president's cabinet nominee. the american people are coming to the conclusion, again fairly or not, and i think it is
fairly, they're coming to the conclusion that this party just wants to wreck and ruin, this party has no agenda other than to say no and to obstruct, and i think it's an incredibly dangerous path, not just for the country, but for the republican party as well. >> you know, michael, this is destabilizing and we all know that. we have numbers out there in terms of what it's doing to public moral and expectations. people are very unsettled when they see the government. the only headlines that seem to come out of this town, washington, d.c., shall ones about will the government shut down, will there be an abyss, will there be a government -- what do you call it -- a lockout? will there be the end of the continuing resolution, the failure to meet our debt creating requirements. it goes on and on. i think it's a political purpose here. you may not agree. i think there's a purpose in this, to undermine the government. >> i don't know if it's to undermine the government but i think there is a political purpose and a political calculation by both parties. what takes me aback, chris, is how we always get to this precipice and everyone always acts so shocked we're here. the sequestration was voted on
in 2011 -- 2012 rather. it's not like it was something new that we didn't know was coming. the congress didn't do its job. house, senate, and the white house. the democrats run two-thirds of the government. the republicans in the house, yes, they have been obstinate on spending and taxes but the agenda hasn't changed from the white house or the senate either. where is the budget? >> but why -- you know why -- michael, you know where the democrats agree to the deals because it's the only way to keep government going. the democrats buckle to the republicans. they're practically holding a gun on them saying -- >> oh, really? >> yeah, yeah. oh, yeah, really. why else would a democrat agree to these things? >> because they're part of the problem as much as everybody else in this town who doesn't want to get to the bottom line of solving the problem. so, you know, i get, you know, the president standing up in front of a podium talking about ships running out of fuel midway across the atlantic, but at the end of the day, i mean, what are you doing to put the agenda straight? what is the senate, the house,
and the white house -- >> oh, okay, in other words, i'll get back to the governor on this. i can't understand this argument. if you don't like the way a guy's policies are running, bring down the government. >> that's not it. >> it's always an abyss, a slitdown. >> can we get some real cuts? can we get some real objectives attained in this debate instead of putting -- we get to the same point. i mean, you guys make the same argument every time. you want to shut down the government. maybe -- >> because you're owls -- michael -- lets take a look at this, another point. the president accused republicans of looking like the party of the rich today and challenged them to make a deal if they want to negotiate a way out of the mess right now. >> republicans in congress face a simple choice. are they willing to compromise to protect vital investments in education, in health care, national security, and all the jobs that depend on them or would they rather put hundreds of thousands of jobs and our entire economy at risk just to
protect a few special interest tax loopholes that benefit only the wealthiest americans and biggest corporations? my door is open. i have put tough cuts and reforms on the table. i am willing to work with anybody to get this job done. none of us will get 100 brs of what we want but nobody should want these cuts to go through. >> political damage if the government runs into trouble, governor, say march 1st it begins to creep along, the real implications where we don't have the adequate defense spending moving out through the pipeline, we really do have a lot of shutdowns and people being laid off, i guess it helps the president because he's already starting to point the finger at a leaderless republican party. they don't have a spokesman to come out and say it's not us. but overall, doesn't it bring down the moral of the country and thereby hurt the president as well or more so number i'm wondering how you divide this out in terms of calamity. >> i think in the long term you're right, chris, it does. in the long term it doesn't benefit the president and michael is right about one
thing. we have not had serious discussions about dealing with our debt problem for the next two, three decades, and we've got to do that. but time is running out and we're not going to do that in the next eight days. the president did hold out the olive branch where he said let's do a smaller package of cuts and revenue enhancements that he said wouldn't kick the can down the road but, in fact, it would kick the can down the road but it's a whole lot better than shutting the government down. and where the republicans are in a hole is the basic revenue increase that the democrats are talking about is the rule that says anyone who makes more than $1 million has to pay a certain amount of taxes regardless. no more loopholes, no more getting out of paying taxes, no more warren buffett is paying a lower rate than their secretaries. the american people agree with that by 75%, 80%. >> but, governor, we just did that. >> it's an untenable position. >> didn't we just do that? >> no. didn't we just raise taxes on the top 1%.
>> you did -- >> oh, okay, i thought we did. >> but, michael, but with good accountants, and you know this, with good accountants -- >> we got to really stick it to them. >> they wind up 15%. not wind up sticking it them. >> michael, do you think we have a fair tax system. are you defending our tax system? are you saying we don't need tax reform? >> chris, i'm all for tax reform but none of this is serious right now. this is the same old crazy blame, blame, finger point, fanger point. no one is getting the job done here. >> okay. that's your assessment. >> tax reform, revenue enhancements, spending cuts, those are the things that need -- where is simpson/bowles part two? we're not talking about it. >> here is boehner talking for boehner. saying once again the president offer nod credible plan that can pass congress, only more calls for higher taxes, just last month the president got his higher taxes on the wealthy, that's what you said, michael, and he's already back for more. here is my assessment of what's going on. back in the early '50s when the
cold war got started, if we didn't like a foreign government the way it was doing things whether it's guatemala or iran or dominican republic or chile, we destabilized it, knocked off the leader. now we're doing it to our own country. and the republicans are acknowledging the tactics, you know. you know that's what they're doing. they're destabilizing the government. you can answer. i see it happening every couple months now. >> but you act like republicans aren't small business owners, that they're not cool teachers and firefighters and policemen, that they're not as affected by these -- the impact of this government as is anyone else is. so the idea that we want to bring down the government is just silly. what we're trying to do is get the government to pay its bills, not spend more than it needs to, check its size, and basically get out of the way of building -- rebuilding this economy. that's all. >> yes, but the congress people are shutting the government down are still making their 170 a year whether the government
shuts down or not. it's not the small businessmen voting in congress. it's the members of congress who think they will get re-elect fd they say no to everything. governor, we have never seen anything like this in our lifetime. a political party which seems to be run now by people who believe that no is a policy. >> no question, chris, and it's damaging to their brand. it's damaging to the long-run future of the republican party, but it's sad because it's also damaging to the country. >> and what are we going to do about it? michael, the president says his door is open. would you go through that door or -- >> i would go in that door in a heartbeat as long as he was still in the room. >> well, i think its a safe bet he's going to stay in the oval office and wait for you. >> that room has many doors. so while i may go in one, he may go out the other. so the bottom line is they all need to get in the same room -- >> you think it's some island in the caribbean where there's just an address on it, there's nobody there. no, this is the real thing. it's called the united states government michael steele and some day the republicans will
get to run it. in the meantime i think they're just going to detonate it. thank you, michael steele. >> we are running a third of it anyway. >> sometimes you have a hard case to make here. thank you grve rendell. >> good to see you. save my seat. with retirees piling up and lots of democrats running in red states, the outlook for 2014 looks challenging for democrats, but 2012 was supposed to be the tough year, too, and democrats wound up gaining senate seats. well, tonight, the democratic strategist, he really exists, with the right stuff who made it happen last time. he's going to come on and talk about whether he can do it again. this is the sharpy behind the democrats big wins in the senate. also the politics of redenks. ing in new about a politician caught in a romantic or simply a sexual affair trying to make a comeback, but few have been caught as former south carolina governor mark sanford was. yet, here he is now trying to rewrite the book of love and politics. plus courtesy of david letterman, things you don't want to hear from a man dressed up like abraham lincoln.
>> number ten. >> how about you and i form a more perfect union? >> best in a long time on letterman. more in the "sideshow." finally let me finish with how the republicans are doing here in the united states, what they once did with governments overseas they didn't like. this is "hardball," the place for politics. mine was earned in djibouti, africa, 2004. the battle of bataan, 1942. [ all ] fort benning, georgia, in 1999. [ male announcer ] usaa auto insurance is often handed down from generation to generation because it offers a superior level of protection and because usaa's commitment to serve the military, veterans, and their families is without equal. begin your legacy. get an auto-insurance quote. usaa. we know what it means to serve. the people of bp made a commitment to the gulf., and every day since, we've worked hard to keep it. today, the beaches and gulf are open for everyone to enjoy.
we've shared what we've learned, so we can all produce energy more safely. bp's also committed to america. we support nearly two-hundred-fifty thousand jobs and invest more here than anywhere else. we're working to fuel america for generations to come. our commitment has never been stronger. the good news for congress is that its approval rating is holding steady. ed bad news, it's stuck at 15%. a new gallup poll finds that fewer than 1 in 7 americans approve the job congress is doing. that's the same approval rating congress suffered with on average throughout all of 2012. 8 in 10 americans disapprove of the job congress is doing. we'll be right back. but not y, you may be muddling through allergies. try zyrtec-d®. powerful relief of nasal congestion and other allergy symptoms -- all in one pill. zyrtec-d®. at the pharmacy counter.
[ babies crying ] is that its approval rating is the job congress is doing. onn a. [ ghosts moaning ] surprise -- your car needs a new transmission. [ coyote howls ] how about no more surprises? now you can get all the online trading tools you need without any surprise fees. ♪ it's not rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade. hi victor! mom? i know you got to go in a minute but this is a real quick meal, that's perfect for two! campbell's chunky beef with country vegetables, poured over rice! [ male announcer ] campbell's chunky soup. it fills you up right.
becomes much easier when the party controls both the house and the senate, of course. it's a tough challenge for 2014 when you look at the map. mark begich in alaska, mark pryer in ashe, mary landrieu, mack baucus, kay haguen and tim johnson are all looking at potentially tough races in states mitt romney won as will the democrat who runs for jay rockefeller's seat in wsk. nor is it a cake walk in the few blue states either. for example in iowa, minnesota where you have democrats running for the senate. conservatives see a big opportunity. they took a look at this front page story as we did in the washington times today. quote, obama agenda is risky for red state democrats. guy cecil has good news for democrats. he pulled a rabbit, rather a donkey, out of his hat last year when the democrats gained seats. actually gained seats in a year that looked like a sure loser for democrats. that's his job to pull off another miracle and hang onto the senate. maggie has beenerman is at
politi politico, a senior politico reporter. this is important although it's a year and a half off, people want to know how obama is going to make it. is he going to put points on the board, immigration reform, something on gun safety. he be likes to talk about himself being a center left version i think of a ronald reagan meaning he wants to get into the history books. the question is can he do it with a republican house? probably not. he's hoping to switch it. let's talk about the senate, however. a lot of people in the democratic party are lucky to be in the senate because they don't match up with the way those states vote in presidential elections. is this a danger? >> well, it's always a danger. the question is how do you deal with it? >> how do you beat the spread? >> we have a road map from what happened in 2012. we don't have to guess about what was going to happen. there was no one daying we passed the affordable care act, that's an easy vote so we can move on to something else. our incumbents last cycle voted for tough things time after time and they won. we had five senators win in
states the president lost. heidi heitkamp upon in north dakota. the president lost by 21 points. the way do you it is you represent the people of your state. people in north dakota are the same as anywhere else. they don't want a xerox machine as their senator that looks at where the president votes and does the same thing. they want something that represents their state and the thing we have to learn is the lesson the republicans are trying to teach us. the fastest way to be a minority party is to have a long list of things that everyone has to check off in order to be a member of the party. if we're going to win in manhattan and in minot, we have to be able to actually talk to both sets of people at the same time and we got to have people that represent their states and we have to be a party that's willing to allow people to vote their conscience. >> i'm looking at a couple of the senators who are women, kay haguen in north carolina, mag zbi, and, of course, mary landrieu, she escapes the vengeance of the right every six years. she manages to get re-elected down there by being careful and by being very respectful of the local attitudes about politics, especially like guns in
louisiana and immigration, of course, down there. if you're the democratic leader, do you want to advise people to vote with the majority and help them pass bills or save themselves? >> i think you're going to see a little bit of both not to step on guy's territory here. but i think that you will see some public boosterism and you will see people privately getting a pass. i think you have seen it in response to immigration in the last couple days with some of the senators you have discussed a minute ago who are not offering up huge stands in support of getting something done immediately. they're taking more of a wait and see attitude. i think you're going to see a lot of that. where i think you will see it more, however, is on guns. i think that's going to be much tougher sell. >> well, we were talking about it before we went on and my concern watching politics, not being in it, is the gun people, the second amendment people who are really ferocious on that issue and fairly so. that's their position. it's democracy. they don't forget. so michael bloomberg can go into a state and he could potentially, he's not going to do it, drop $5 million or $10
million. he's doing in the south side in chicago but he's going to leave. he's going to go into other issues. wind energy or something he's interested in and that person is still there trying to get re-elected. >> the fact of the matter is we're not going to get 100% of all democratic votes for every piece of gun control legislation that goes through the senate. we are going -- >> if you were harry reid and you work with him and the democrats, would you encourage him to expose people like mark pryor down in arkansas and max baucus out in montana? would you ask them to vote on an assault weapons ban? >> i think harry reid will give them the same advice i give them in private which is when you agree with the president, you should say so. and when you disagree with the president -- >> don't buckle from pressure from the white house. >> we have seen mark pryor has come out in opposition. i suspect you will see a couple others, but i would just juxtapose that against what's happening on the other side. the reason we're starting in the senate first is because john boehner and the leaders on the house side can't get anything done. they can't get a majority of their own party to support the speaker's own -- >> do you realize how their
strategy could work. you and the senate will be the first cut. you are the first guys going over the top in world war 1 blowing the whistles, cutting through the con ser tina wire. you guys could get mowed down. i'm thinking about pryor, begich, landrieu, haguen, tim johnson. they all have to vote up or down. what happens is the house which is run by republicans, they don't have to take on issues like that because they've already been beaten. >> here is the difference. the republican party is running people like myrrh you can do and todd akin and christine o'donnell -- >> if you're lucky again. >>er eschewing everybody he else. when lugar and cassell aren't conservative enough, what does the republican party do? they throw them out. we embrace folks from louisiana and arkansas and they're not going to vote with us all the time and we have to accept that fact. but the fact -- >> maggie, let me ask you this. what happens when they don't have these lucky jokers in the deck like akin and mourdock. they were really gifts to these people. >> they were. >> what happens if they don't show up in 2014 because people
like rove and others have culled the herd? >> i think there's no question that democrats got lucky last year. republicans had a pretty poor crop of candidates. you had some candidates, senate candidates, republicans, who lost in states mitt romney won. so you can't only blame mitt romney. however, i also think you have to give guy and his team credit in terms of recruitment. it's not just the other side. but i think that there's no question 2014 is probably going to be a much tougher year for democrats than last one was. i think a lot of things came, you know, were aligned well. some were proactive by the democrats, some were not. but i think that it's going to be different and it's playing out on a different legislative climate. >> total congressional question, maggie, you start. does the president need to win the house next time and hold the senate to be a president of history? to get the kinds of bills passed that puts you up there at the top presidents? >> no. but it would help, and i don't think it's going to happen. i don't think they're going to win the house. >> i certainly think it's going to be difficult for both those things to happen but i would agree with maggie.
juke hold the senate though, can't you? >> we intend to hold the senate. no one thought we could hold it last cycle. not only did we hold it, we picked up seats. nobody was saying tommy thompson was extreme. we won because we recruited candidates that best fit their state. >> you know what i have to say, what i care about, you know what i respect in politics? people like the people on this list. >> me, too. >> anybody can come from a big city and vote 100% ada and be guaranteed a seat for life. when you're out there on the frontier as a moderate democrat and trying to get elected among moderate democrats in your state, maybe you have 50% of the states moderate democrats, you have to prove yourself every six years, prove yourself to the people out there. and that's really gutsy. great stuff. good luck. you got great ink today. don't think it's going to stay that way. it never stays that way. guy cecil. it's like baseball managers, they have one good world series season. >> i'll take it. i'll take one. >> thank you very much, guy cecil. good to have you back, maggie. up next, things you done
want to hear from a guy dressed up like abraham lincoln. this is the best david letterman top ten i have heard in so long and it's coming up. >> damn girl, you make mary todd look like ulysses s. grant. i have low testosterone. there, i said it. how did i know? well, i didn't really. see, i figured low testosterone would decrease my sex drive... but when i started losing energy and became moody... that's when i had an honest conversation with my doctor. we discussed all the symptoms... then he gave me some blood tests.
showed it was low t. that's it. it was a number -- not just me. [ male announcer ] today, men with low t have androgel 1.62% (testosterone gel). the #1 prescribed topical testosterone replacement therapy, increases testosterone when used daily. women and children should avoid contact with application sites. discontinue androgel and call your doctor if you see unexpected signs of early puberty in a child, or signs in a woman, which may include changes in body hair or a large increase in acne, possibly due to accidental exposure. men with breast cancer or who have or might have prostate cancer, and women who are or may become pregnant or are breastfeeding, should not use androgel. serious side effects include worsening of an enlarged prostate, possible increased risk of prostate cancer, lower sperm count, swelling of ankles, feet, or body, enlarged or painful breasts, problems breathing during sleep, and blood clots in the legs. tell your doctor about your medical conditions and medications, especially insulin, this is the best david letterman so...what do men do when a number's too low? turn it up!
[ male announcer ] in a clinical study, over 80% of treated men had their t levels restored to normal. talk to your doctor about all your symptoms. get the blood tests. change your number. turn it up. androgel 1.62%. get the blood tests. change your number. turn it up. try running four.ning a restaurant is hard, fortunately we've got ink. it gives us 5x the rewards on our internet, phone charges and cable, plus at office supply stores. rewards we put right back into our business. this is the only thing we've ever wanted to do and ink helps us do it. make your mark with ink from chase. otherworldly things. but there are some things i've never seen before. this ge jet engine can understand 5,000 data samples per second. which is good for business. because planes use less fuel, spend less time on the ground and more time in the air.
suddenly, faraway places don't seem so...far away. ♪ back to "hardball" now to the "sideshow." first david letterman brought on washington's birthday or president's day as a lot of people call it by showing us what happens when you send an abe lincoln look houst-alike to streets of new york city. what you don't want to hear from a guy dressed like lincoln. >> number ten. >> how about you and i form a more perfect union? >> number eight? >> daniel day-lewis wishes he looked this good. >> that's right. number seven. >> is it true bloomberg outlawed
hats over 16 ounces? >> number five? >> does the $5 bill make me look fat? >> number four. >> wow, i thought my clothing was outdated. >> number two. >> hey, where is my idiot son, abraham wmpl lincoln? >> and the number one thing you don't want to hear from a guy dressed as abraham lincoln. >> hey, jackass, are you going to thank me for the day off? >> i say number two takes the cake. where is w.? as we talked about earlier we're down to the wire when it comes to avoiding big chops in government spending so alan simpson wants to know why the deficit reduction plan he put together with erskine bowles wasn't carried out. >> i say to people before you, you know, begin to drool at the mouth and go crazy and scratch our eyeballs out, read the damn report. people say, what are you doing to the vulnerable? i say read it. we don't do anything to people on ssi. we don't do anything with food stamp. we don't do anything with people on unemployment.
get your -- use your bean instead of listening to crap all day long from the right and the left. >> that's actually pretty tame compared to some other things he said about the folks involved in deficit reduction talks. >> if you have -- if you're a politician and get up and say i know we're going to get this done, get rid of all earmarks, all waste fraud and abuse, all foreign aid, air force one, all kngsal pensions, that's a sparrow belch in the midst of a typhoon. quit the phoniness, a lot of blood hair and eyeballs have to lay on the floor. quit the hypocrisy. quit the disgust. quit embarrassing america. this is a suicide mission. we'll get it from all sides, the right, the left. everybody knows you don't like each other and you're trying to pretend you do. give up the pettiness. go see the movie lincoln. >> go see the movie lincoln. that last bit of advice makes sense. before you can do something grand you need to know what grand looks like. i think simpson is playing an important part in pointing to
what's possible in dealing with the debt crisis. up next, former south carolina governor mark sanford is back. he fell hard after being caught having an extramarital affair. now he's seeking the daddy of all political comebacks. he's running for the congress, and that's ahead, and you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. you are a business. omnipotent of opportunity. you know how to mix business... with business. and you...rent from national. because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle. and go. you can even take a full-size or above. and still pay the mid-size price. i could get used to this. [ male announcer ] yes, you could business pro. yes, you could. go national. go like a pro. [ female announcer ] for beautiful dry mornings, there's pampers. unlike other diapers, pampers has 3 absorbent layers, for up to 12 hours of protection overnight. pampers.
♪ i don't wanna be right [ record scratch ] what?! it's not bad for you. it just tastes that way. [ female announcer ] honey nut cheerios cereal -- heart-healthy, whole grain oats. you can't go wrong loving it. [ male announcer ] were you more interesting in your twenties, or now? when you were starting out? or after a few decades working in some well-worn character? experience makes you wiser for the wear. and now come the richer possibilities. [ children laughing ] aarp. an ally for real possibilities. find tools and resources at aarp.org/possibilities.
wherever you are today, a fidelity ira has a wide range of investment choices to help you fine-tune your personal economy. call today and we'll make it easy to move that old 401(k) to a fidelity no-fee ira. i'm bertha coombs with your cnbc market wrap. a fresh five-year high for the dow which gained 54 points on the day. the s&p 500 rose 11 and the nasdaq finished up 21 with google shares now over $800. they rose nearly $14 today getting that mark for the first time. as for the economy, home builder sentiment slipped this month while a gain was expected. and after the closing bell, dell reported earnings of revenue
that exceeded estimates. the stock is slightly higher after hours. that's it from cnbc, we're first in business worldwide. now back to "hardball." ♪ more recently i have experienced how none of us go through life without mistakes, but in their wake we can learn a lot about grace, a god of second chances, and be the better for it. in that light i humble bistep forward and ask for your help in changing washington. i'm mark sanford, and i approve this message. >> welcome back to "hardball." that's former south carolina governor mark sanford who is trying to resurrect his political career with a bid to fill the open house seat in south carolina's first congressional district. to refresh your memory about this mistake he references in the ad here is a clip from his famous june 2009 press conference. >> i have been unfaithful to my
wife. i developed a relationship with a -- what started as a dear, dear friend from argentina. it began very innocently, as i suspect many of these things do, in just a casual e-mail back and forth in advice on one's life there and advice here. but here recently over this last year it developed into something much more than that. >> well, now mark sanford is trying to use his transgression as a building block, if you will, for a revived political career telling politico, i probably have more to offer now as a human being than at any point in my life because there's an added level of reflection, of empathy. joining me is michelle cottle of "newsweek" and the daily wiest and john nak colonels of the nation. you're laughing, john. this is serious business. let's get started here.
michelle, this is interesting because the use of the word mistake is fascinating. i mean, you can do an exegesis of that word. was the mistake falling in love and going off -- he's apparently still with this woman. he's been divorced. what was the mistake he acknowledges here? i can't even figure out how to discern what he's talking about sometimes with these guys but he's learned a lot from it and he has much better empathy and much more reflective in life. >> that's right. >> so he made a mistake but he's somehow better for it. explain how that works. >> you have to focus on how he's learned, chris. he's grown, he understands humility and self-reflection and compassion. this is a guy who didn't just cheat on his wife. this is a guy who cheated on his wife, loo i had to his constituents, told them he disappeared from office and then humiliated himself and the state by rambling on and on and on about his soulmate and how he had fallen in love. so it takes -- you have to unravel this whole thing to even begin to understand kind of what he's apologizing for. >> yeah, i'm not sure the word mistake is applicable here. and i am having a little fun
with this because i think it's ridiculous -- not that politicians have emotions if they make moral errors and they sin or whatever, but that they had the craziest way of write being it and talking about it with the voter. john nichols, was the mistake when he thought he was on the appalachian trail somewhere down in the united states along the mountains, he was actually in buenos aries. i thought i was on the appalachian trail. that's a mistake. that's when you make a mistake. his mistake was he fell in love, fine. what did he do that he considers a mistake and what does he benefit in terms of the voters going back to d.c.? is he bringing the woman from argentina with him back to d.c.? where does he stand on this thing? >> well, it gets pretty wild, doesn't it, because all the questions you ask are appropriate ones. and the first question really is, if he had made a bigger mistake, if he had done something worse, would he be better qualified for congress? because that seems to be the argument he's making. and, of course, the reality of it is the biggest mistake he
made was lying. he lied to his own staff. he lied to the people of south carolina. and he got caught in an enormous way. >> what should he have done? now that we're doing this, now that we're meantoring him in reverse, in retrospect, what should he have done? told everyone i was down in buenos aires with this woman i met and it got serious and i guess i'm in a situation. would that have worked? >> here is a tip. if you're going to buenos aries to have an affair, at least acknowledge that you're going to buenos aries. don't claim you're out hiking on the appalachian trail. >> okay. now, just to put this in perspective, newt gingrich is always useful in putting things in per sec tiff. there are a lot of ways to attempt a political comeback. newt gingrich used a different approach to explain his infidelity in a 2011 interview. this is only two years ago. let's listen to the newt sister becau ster because he beats the band when it comes to this stuff. >> there's no question at times in my life partially driven by
how passionately i felt about this country, that i worked far too hard and that things happened in my life that were not appropriate. >> so he was too patriotic. he cared too much about the country. he worked too hard for the country and then things happened because he was patriotic and worked too hard for the country. what is that? is that a mistake or is that some kind of way of talking? >> this once again is a selling point. it's the, you see, i love my country so much i just -- i kind of lost my head and, oops, i'm so sorry i left my wife for another woman. it's unfortunate. >> when you say something which is as full of malarkey as that, who do you expect to believe it, that you were too patriotic, that you couldn't remember who your wife was or -- i don't want to make moral judgment i'll just talk politics here. i don't understand why they think people have such dunce caps on out there, oh, that's a
point. he really is too patriotic to be faithful to his wife. i mean, what are we talking about with these people? that's why they don't trust politicians. >> maybe he wanted to make mark san forward look good. >> congress is running 15% approval because people talk like this and they say things like i made a mistake. >> they're providing some thin veneer of cover for people who want an excuse to go back and believe in them. you know, you need some way to justify yourself -- >> you just described a criminal defense. somebody told me to take the car. i didn't tale it. >> we're not talking about politics. >> let's talk turkey. i want to know if the guy can win. i'm hearing different reports he could easily win in a very wide field. there is a runoff though. runoffs are always dangerous for people with troubles. you eventually have to run against one other person for your party's nomination. it's a republican district but he has owe to beat one republican.
can he be a congressman again despite everything we've been kidding about here? >> the truth is this is a very good ad. it's a well-done ad. and down in that district he has been getting a reasonably good response. now, it's a very crowded field, almost everybody seems to think that mark sanford will come through the initial primary. he'll face one other candidate, but it is possible, certainly not certain, possible that the other candidate he faces might be ted turner's son. >> and namesake. >> and if mark sanford attaches ted turner's record to ted turner's son, yeah, i could see a moment where mark sanford might get through a runoff and get to congress. >> so an embarrassment beats a legacy. >> exactly. he's not high name recollection and erick erickson was one of his biggest detractors and the minute he started this confessional tour, ericsson is i forgive him, let's be graceful and give him other shot.
>> it's not rural south carolina. it's not cottonland. it's very beautiful charlton, one of the most beautiful cities in the world i think. are those people up to this kind of level of life? this sort of way of looking at things, this kay sir ra sir ra. do they have enough of that to vote for him? mark? i'm sorry, not mark, john. we're talking about mark. >> it is within the realm -- that's okay. although i hope my wife doesn't make the comparison. >> no, you're not mark. >> it's within the realm of possibility, and understand that charlton, like new orleans, is a pretty sophisticated city, and there will be some folks who may want to try and forgive, but also who may want to try and look the other way. one thing that's important to understand is mark sanford aside from his incredible bumbles on this, you know, back in 2009, has always been a very capable politician and by comparison to some of the other candidates he comes off pretty well for folks in charles to be. >> i think the most forgiving
city in the country is new orleans. i think when you're fourth or fifth divorce you go to new orleans. you have been through new orleans, they say come in and have some fun. in the "today" show sanford touted his record of looking out for taxpayers. let's listen. >> the reality of our lives is if we live long enough we're going to fail at something. and i absolutely failed in my personal life, in my marriage, but one place i didn't ever fail was with the taxpayer. >> the south carolina state ethics commission doesn't agree. sanford settled charges he broke ethics laws by using state and campaign money for personal travel guess where, including travel to argentina by paying a $74,000 fine. yet, the state reported in the graeme the ethics commission issued a public reprimand and disagreed with his argument that he broke no laws. well, there we have it, right? >> yeah. in this way he can lump this all in with his personal transgressions and say jesus has forgiven me and so should you.
>> maybe he has. that we don't know. that last thing you said. anyway, thank you michelle cottle and thank you john nichols for this serious report on an unserious man. we have much more on mark sanford's tour on our website. check out -- it's on facebook as well. up next, that sad saga from south africa where oscar pistorius, the world's most famous pair olympian has been charged with murdering his girlfriend. buzz bissinger said it's time to stop this unwarranted veneration of sports figures we have grown up with. he joins us next, and this is "hardball," the place for politics. so delicious? because every flake is double-toasted... splashed with sweet honey... and covered in rich double-roasted peanuts. mmm. [ hero ] yummy. [ male announcer ] kellogg's crunchy nut. it's super delicious! [ male announcer ] kellogg's crunchy nut. if your a man with low testosterone, you should know that axiron is here. the only underarm treatment for low t. that's right, the one you apply to the underarm. axiron is not for use in women or anyone younger than 18.
axiron can transfer to others through direct contact. women, especially those who are or who may become pregnant, and children should avoid contact where axiron is applied as unexpected signs of puberty in children or changes in body hair or increased acne in women may occur. report these signs and symptoms to your doctor if they occur. tell your doctor about all medical conditions and medications. do not use if you have prostate or breast cancer. serious side effects could include increased risk of prostate cancer; worsening prostate symptoms; decreased sperm count; ankle, feet, or body swelling; enlarged or painful breasts; problems breathing while sleeping; and blood clots in the legs. common side effects include skin redness or irritation where applied, increased red blood cell count, headache, diarrhea, vomiting, and increase in psa. see your doctor, and for a 30-day free trial, go to axiron.com. [ male announcer ] why do more emergency workers everywhere trust duracell...?? duralock power preserve. locks in power for up to 10 years in storage. now...guaranteed. duracell with duralock.
girlfriend. buzz bissinger says it's time to there was a flurry of questions in today's white house press briefing about what kind of communications president obama has had with those key republicans on immigration reform. late today the white house put out word. the president called up senators lindsey graham, john mccain, and marco rubio to support their efforts on the issue and urged the senate to pass a bill as soon as possible. senator rubio's office tells nbc news the senator appreciated the president's call and is hopeful they can come up with a bill that will win bipartisan support. we will be right back. that is good news. ♪ [ male announcer ] how could a luminous protein in jellyfish,
impact life expectancy in the u.s., real estate in hong kong, and the optics industry in germany? at t. rowe price, we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. it's just one reason over 75% of our mutual funds beat their 10-year lipper average. t. rowe price. invest with confidence. request a prospectus or summary prospectus with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing.
we're back. we've now all heard the sorry of oscar pistorius, the inspiring double amp tee olympic athlete being held for killing his girlfriend down in south africa. the blade runner as he's called has been charged with murdering his 30-year-old model girlfriend reeva steenkamp in the early morning hours of valentine's day. pistorius was in court again today pleading innocent. prosecutors said it was premeditated murder. fans were stunned when they heard about the incident, stunned their hero might be capable of such as an act as murder. let's think about this. why are we so quick to give athletes the hero title thinking they are super on and off the field? now pistorius joins the club of other athleteses who have fallen far from hev, o.j. simpson, mark m a-rod, lance armstrong, tiger woods. all had a hard fall from grace for various degrees of evil you might say. joining me right now is buzz
bizzinger. jocks, we look up to them. from high school to college they get waited on, they get their own dorms. they get looked up to by the cheerleaders and the fans. they're treated as special. what's wrong with that? >> when you're treated as special, you think you're special but not in an open sense. you think you're entitled. you become spoiled. you become more narcissistic than you already are. and they're not role models. we heart attaarken back to the . by and large they've never been role models. mickey mantle was not a great role model. you went down the list. lance armstrong. now oscar pistorius. we want them to be mythic because they have such influence on kids. but you know what? they're just athletes.
let them just be athletes. stop this role model b.s. >> you know, when they -- when sport magazine came out in the '50s, they had to pick the best athlete. and they picked moouz yell over williams because of who he was off the field. ted did all those awful things to fans. giving whatever he did, signaling the fans. and having an attitude. aren't there great athletes that are worthy of the adoration like moouz yell who just died? >> in anticipation of the show, i've really thought about it. i thought about it since i wrote the daily beast column. i can think definitely of one. that is derek jeter of the yankees. classy. good to fans. plays really, really hard all the time. i am confident of him. the second might surprise you, but i think given the exposure
that this guy has gotten since he was a junior in high school, i think lebron james has come into his own and is a role model. he made a bad mistake with the decision, but he hasn't shot anybody. he's good with fans. he supports akron. and i think he handles -- he's one of the four or five most famous athletes in the world. >> he lost to dallas and came back and won the next year. i want to get back to the bad names. of course o.j. simpson. maybe in 20 years we'll decide his guilt. i think he did it. i understand the police history got in there. but these guys, let's talk about how their heads get so big. they think they can get away with murder. they get away with things. that is the thing you're talking about that's brilliant. the writing that -- when you teach a person to be a bad guy. you're prometian. do what you want. >> you're right. the age is going lower and lower and lower. good athletes are being
identified as young as five, six, seven. the minute you're identified as good athlete, you are put over here. you are special. you have different standards. you don't have to do as much work. you are coddled. you are coddled by adults. you are coddled by kids that want to be like you. you get too popular and it's going to lead in too many cases to disaster. >> yeah. i just think about guys that play for the nba. got an entourage of 15 hangers on. then all of a sudden they're out of money and the entourage is gone. where are they? they're gone. what's that do to you? >> of course they're gone. it's a tragedy. studies have been done. 50% of former nba players are broke. i spoke to an agent who said these guys are in such a bubble, they get these big contracts, but they don't -- chris, they don't know they have to pay taxes. they have no idea. they buy four houses, they buy four cars. you know, look at allen iverson.
he's broke. >> that's who i was thinking of. >> he has no money. >> let me help kids out that are athletes. look at magic. the opposite. a good business guy. a guy who caught on even with his health challenges. it's chilling to think he's overcome what he's overcome. not only be a popular figure and role model but also become a business guy. it's so hard to do that. mantle couldn't do that. >> mantle was a disaster until the memorabilia boom. listen. there are role models after sports. what about dave bing? >> he's doing a good job as mayor. >> johnson in sacramento. former nba player. chris dudley in oregon. there are guys who go on and have a sense of public service. >> i think you're right. let's not prejudge these guys' greatness. prove it off the court, off the field. buzz bissinger. let me finish tonight with what the republicans are doing here in the united states. in a weird way it's the same thing they did back in the early
'50s, toppling governments. unfortunately this time it's our government they're trying to topple. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. how do you keep an older car running like new? you ask a ford customer. when they tell you that you need your oil changed you got to bring it in. if your tires need to be rotated, you have to get that done as well. jackie, tell me why somebody should bring they're car here to the ford dealership for service instead of any one of those other places out there. they are going to take care of my car because this is where it came from. price is right no problem, they make you feel like you're a family. get a synthetic blend oil change, tire rotation and much more, $29.95 after $10.00 rebate. if you take care of your car your car will take care of you. [ bop ] [ bop ] [ bop ] you can do that all you want, i don't like v8 juice. [ male announcer ] how about v8 v-fusion. a full serving of vegetables, a full serving of fruit.
a talking car. but i'll tell you what impresses me. a talking train. this ge locomotive can tell you exactly where it is, what it's carrying, while using less fuel. delivering whatever the world needs, when it needs it. ♪ after all, what's the point of talking if you don't have something important to say? ♪